Sure, a new pair of shoes or an It bag is nice, but many of us are more wiling to shell out a chunk of our paychecks for quality skin care, all in the name of #iwokeuplikethis status. That said, there are a myriad of things in the way of finding a complexion potion that’ll actually lead you on a path to improving your biggest skin-care issues. Namely, lots of confusing marketing jargon, and campaigns that promise flawless complexions, but don’t always deliver.
The pattern seems to go like this: The more effective a product claims to be, the more dollar signs are involved. Serums are some of the most spendy, since time and time again they prove to be the most important part of your routine, as they oft pack the most active ingredient and go on first, allowing them to soak in and do the most good.
Naturally, it takes a lot of sussing out to figure out which serums are worth the splurge. To cut through the BS, we consulted top dermatologists for direct recommendations. These serums get the clinical green light, and while their campaigns and packaging might be less sexy than your pretty vials or countless bottles of fancy face oil, we have to ask: What’s fancier than a flawless face? That’s kind of the whole point, anyway.
Ahead, the serums that top dermatologists call the most effective — and recommend to their own patients — all organized by skin-care concern.
Skin Concern: Dryness
Chronically dry skin needs more than just the shellac of a thick moisturizer to actually solve the problem — and not just treat the symptoms. One of the top ingredients to do that is hyaluronic acid.
“What’s great about [hyaluronic acid] is that it doesn’t feel like a heavy moisturizer, but it does the work of one,” says Dr. Dendy Engelman,
director of dermatologic surgery and laser medicine at Metropolitan Hospital.
“Hyaluronic acid helps your skin retain moisture by binding water molecules, holding 1,000 times its weight.” Dr. Engelman recommends this serum from Derm Institute for its hydrating abilities, as well as for its ability to repair and protect, thanks to a ceramide complex, vitamins, and antioxidants, which plump fine lines and combat free radicals from environmental damage.
Derm Institute Antioxidant Hydration Serum, $100, available Derm Institute.
Another formula that serves up hyaluronic acid is this HylaSilk Serum from Priyana MD.
Dr. Barry Resnik, MD, Founder of Resnik Skin Institue in Miami, recommends it not only for the HA, but also the formula’s niacinamide, a brightening ingredient that helps address uneven pigmentation. Bonus: Peptides in the formula give this serum a boost in both hydrating and anti-aging efforts, like promoting collagen and elasticity.
Priyana MD HylaSilk, $55, available at Resnik Skin Institute.
Skin Concern: Uneven Pigmentation and/or Dullness
Dr. Paul Jarrod Frank, a cosmetic dermatologist, touts resveratrol and vitamin C as your best weapons against pigmentation issues, mainly uneven texture or dullness in skin.
“Resveratrol is the strongest natural antioxidant that reduces [uneven] pigmentation and protects the skin from further free radical damage,” Dr. Frank explains. He couples that with a disclaimer that, “there’s no magic ingredient to make [uneven pigmentation] disappear quickly, as the body continues to make the enzyme that stimulates the production of melanin.”
He recommended this night serum from Skinceuticals, since it not only keeps pigmentation in check, it also firms the skin and corrects fine lines. “[It’s] cosmetically elegant and absorbs very well, giving the skin a nice glow,” he says.
Skinceuticals Resveratrol B E, $152, available at Skinceuticals.
This Skinceuticals serum gets a thumbs-up from a handful of the derms we spoke with, including Dr. Engelman, Dr. Frank, and Dr. Elizabeth Tanzi. Pigmentation can come from lifestyle habits like too much sun exposure, smoking, picking at your blemishes, and even genetic predispositions. But the L-ascorbic acid (a highly effective form of vitamin C) is not only great for brightening, it also “contains powerful antioxidants that fight and reverse damage from free radicals that wreck your skin cells,” Dr. Engelman concludes.
Dr. Elizabeth Tanzi, founder and director of
Capital Laser & Skin Care and assistant clinical professor, department of dermatology, at the George Washington University Medical Center, cautions against reaching for a one-serum-fits-all product. “Serums are best used for targeted problems,” she notes. It’s best to look for stable packaging, as many serums contain antioxidants that are light-sensitive. (This formula is packed in a dark bottle to help combat this.)
“Not all vitamin C serums are equal or effective,” Dr. Frank chimes in. “The addition of the ferulic acid in this product helps to stabilize the efficacy of the vitamin C.”
Skinceuticals C E Ferulic Serum, $162, available at Skinceuticals.
Dr. Jessica Weiser of the New York Dermatology Group recommends Colbert MD’s Stimulate Serum to brighten and enliven skin. “This serum contains glycolic acid and antioxidants, in addition to the anti-inflammatory healing herb, gotu kola,” Dr. Weiser explains. “It helps to promote collagen production while simultaneously brightening the skin and reversing signs of free radical damage.”
Those with sensitive skin will appreciate the anti-inflammatory protection of gotu kola, but if you’ve got an aversion to silicones, just note that this one contains dimethicone, so steer clear.
Colbert MD Stimulate Serum, $160, available at Colbert MD.
Skin Concern: Anti-aging
This drugstore pick from
Dr. Valerie Goldburt proves that great serums don’t have to cost an arm and a leg (but still may be more $$ than other drugstore skin-care products).“My favorite is the Olay Regenerist serum with peptides. It’s a low price point compared to the department store equivalent and actually has benefits for the appearance of fine lines,” Dr. Goldburt says.
The amino peptide complex and vitamin B3 in this formula are wrinkle-smoothers, while the rest of the formula works to deeply hydrate your skin, so you get renewed surface cells with increased elasticity and plumpness, she says.
Olay Regenerist Regenerating Serum, $24.99, available at Olay.
If you aren’t sure where to start with serums, but you know your skin could just a magic “enhance” button, this NuGene Universal Serum comes recommended from Dr. Engelman for evening skin texture and tone, all while boosting hydration.
“Ultimately, great skin is hydrated, free of dead skin and impurities, and even-toned,” Dr. Engelman says. The road to great skin starts with exfoliation, but Engelman touts this serum, which contains a few heavy-hitters, like human adipose derived stem cell conditioned media, polypeptides, and amino acids, for a bit of help in that department.
NuGene Universal Serum, $300, available at NuGene.
The most effective way to shield your skin from the signs of aging is protection — but you already knew that. However, you can accomplish this with more than just SPF. Serums containing ceramides, like this one from Elizabeth Arden’s Prevage line, help strengthen skin cells to keep up the repairing and renewing possible when skin is protected.
This serum is also on Dr. Engelman’s top-shelf list.“Serums with retinol help with cell repair and renewal. Retinols are a good ingredient for acne (generally of the cystic kind), but also plumping up fine lines and wrinkles.” This serum relies on something called advanced Idebenone technology, which tops the list of powerful antioxidants for the most protection and repair of your skin.
Elizabeth Arden Prevage Anti-Aging Daily Serum, $162, available at Elizabeth Arden.
Skin Concern: Acne
When you think about well-known anti-aging ingredients, you probably reach for the retinols. This serum is good starter option since it contains a mild 0.2% (to avoid that sometimes red, chemical-burn complexion upon first smear), but Dr. Barry Resnik actually recommends this one for treating acne and rosacea, since it uses caffeine, which helps constrict blood vessels, and 90% green tea polyphenols to neutralize free radicals and give your radiance a leg-up. It’s super lightweight, making it perfect for oily or combination skin types.
Replenix All-trans Retinol Smoothing Serum 2X, $58.80, available at Dermstore.
Keeping acneic skin calm and breakout-free requires a delicate balance, since you don’t want to further clog already-congested pores, but you
also don’t want to dry skin out to the point of a flaky mess. One serum that has both fronts covered comes from iS Clinical.
Its Active Serum, recommended by Dr. Tanzi, is super lightweight, with gentle exfoliators like sugar cane extract, white willow bark extract, and Bilberry extract to gently remove dead skin cells. Arbutin and mushroom extract help reduce hyperpigmentation.
iS Clinical Active Serum, $130, available at Dermstore.
If you’re on the long road out of acne town, you’re probably hoping to treat existing breakouts
and make pigmentation from past acne scars disappear. A serum with L-ascorbic acid, as well as plenty of soothing and anti-inflammatory ingredients, is what you should look for. Dr. Engelman highlights iS Clinical’s Pro-Heal Serum Advance for this express purpose, since it contains plenty of gentle botanical ingredients like olive leaf extract, plus retinols and vitamin E to combat your acne (and fine lines) with plenty of antioxidants.
When it comes to delicate skin issues, Dr. Engelman advises looking at the ingredient ranking. “A red flag for me is when I look at their ingredient list and the active ingredient is at the end, which means the concentration is very little and therefore may not be at its most effective point.”
So, if you’re looking to zap breakouts, make sure those ingredients (i.e., retinols, vitamin C, exfoliators) are at the top, followed by the rest of the supporting cast.
iS Clinical Pro-Heal Serum Advance, $142, available at Dermstore.
Like this post? There’s more. Get tons of beauty tips, tutorials, and news on the
Refinery29 Beauty Facebook page. Like us on Facebook — we’ll see you there!
Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?
8 Amazing Ways Rosewater Can Change Your Beauty Routine
The Best Way To Get Rid Of Acne Scars
The Surprising Thing That Finally Stopped My Breakouts